For early retirees
Retiring early? Let's cover the years before Medicare.
Leave work in your 50s or early 60s and you're buying your own health insurance for years, not months. I'll compare COBRA, Marketplace, and private plans so health insurance doesn't decide when you get to retire.
You're in the right place if
- You're planning to retire in your 50s or early 60s, and health insurance is the piece you haven't figured out.
- Your COBRA quote made you rethink the whole timeline.
- You've saved well, so you may not get much of a Marketplace tax credit.
- You're healthy and don't want to pay full price for coverage you rarely use.
Your options when you retire early
Most early retirees end up choosing from the same four options. The right one depends on your retirement income, your health, and how many years you have until 65.
- COBRA. Keep your employer's plan, usually for up to 18 months, but at the full price.
- A Marketplace plan. Leaving your job gives you 60 days to enroll, and your price depends on your income.
- A private plan. Priced on your age, location, and health instead of your income. Many can start on the first of any month.
- A spouse's work plan, if your spouse is still working and their employer offers family coverage.
COBRA vs. Marketplace vs. private, side by side
| Feature | COBRA | Marketplace plan | Private plan |
|---|---|---|---|
| What you pay | The full premium plus up to 2% | Based on your income, after any tax credit | Based on age, location, and health |
| How long it lasts | Usually up to 18 months | Year to year until Medicare | Year to year, based on the plan's terms |
| Health questions | None | None | Usually, before you're approved |
| Your doctors | Same plan, same network | New plan, so check the network | New plan, so check the network |
| When you can sign up | During your COBRA election period, usually 60 days | Within 60 days of losing work coverage, or at open enrollment | Any time of year, for many plans |
| Usually the better fit for | A few months, mid-treatment | Lower retirement income or health conditions | Healthy retirees over the subsidy line |
Every situation is different, so I'll price all three for you before you decide.
How the Marketplace counts retirement income
Marketplace tax credits are based on your income for the year, not on how much you've saved. That can work in your favor if you live on savings, and against you if you don't plan for it.
- Most withdrawals from a traditional IRA or 401(k) count as income.
- Social Security counts, including the part that isn't taxed.
- Qualified Roth withdrawals don't count.
Under current law, tax credits generally stop above 400% of the federal poverty level, about $86,560 for a couple for 2027 coverage. Go a dollar over and you pay full price. A pension or one big IRA withdrawal can put you over the line, so plan your withdrawals with your tax professional.
Offered health insurance at work?
If you or your spouse can get job-based coverage that counts as affordable, that person generally can't get a Marketplace tax credit, at any income. For 2027, it counts as affordable if the employee's share for employee-only coverage is 10.22% of household income or less. Family members are judged on the cost of family coverage.
Why COBRA is usually a short bridge
COBRA keeps your doctors and your plan, which is why it can make sense for a few months, especially in the middle of treatment. But you pay the whole premium your employer used to help cover, plus up to 2%, and it usually ends after 18 months. Retire at 57, and you'd still need about six and a half more years of coverage after COBRA runs out.
Timing matters here. Leaving your job opens a 60-day window to pick a Marketplace plan. If you take COBRA and drop it on your own after that window closes, you don't get a new one. You'd have to wait for open enrollment or for COBRA to run out.
Where private plans fit
Marketplace prices rise with age, and older adults can be charged up to three times what younger people pay before tax credits. If your income is over the subsidy line, you pay all of it.
Private plans are priced on age, location, and health instead. For healthy early retirees who don't qualify for a tax credit, they often cost less, and many can start on the first of any month, so your coverage can pick up the day after your work plan ends. They can use medical underwriting, so not everyone qualifies. That's why I show you both before you decide.
Plan the whole stretch to 65
The best time to sort this out is a month or two before your last day, so there's no gap. If your spouse is younger than you, we'll plan their coverage too, since they'll still need a plan of their own after you move to Medicare. Your Medicare sign-up window opens three months before the month you turn 65.
What I'll compare for you
- What COBRA would cost you each month
- Marketplace prices at your expected retirement income
- Private plan prices for your age and health
- Whether your doctors are in network
- Coverage for a spouse who's younger than you
- The right start date, so there's no gap
What clients say
Dalton was absolutely amazing to work with! He was incredibly helpful, knowledgeable, and professional throughout the entire process. He went above and beyond to make sure everything was explained clearly and made the whole experience smooth and stress-free. You can tell he genuinely cares about his clients and truly wants the best for them. I couldn't be happier with the service I received. I highly recommend Dalton. Outstanding service all around!
Wonderful! He was and continues to be such great help! We were paying a lot for insurance through my husband's work and Dalton helped us find the perfect plan in our budget. Highly recommend! I'm always suggesting him to my family and friends.
I was tired of overpaying for poor coverage, and Dalton walked me through some great options in a very professional way. I'll definitely be recommending him to friends and family.
Buying health insurance from Dalton was a great experience. He explained everything clearly, helped me pick the right plan, and made the whole process easy. I'm really happy with the outcome!
Get your exact quote
Tell me a little about your situation and I'll put your private and Marketplace options side by side. I usually reach out within one business day, and there's never a cost to you.
- Private and Marketplace plans compared side by side
- One licensed advisor, no call center
- No cost and no obligation
Early retirement questions
Don't see your question? Browse all questions or text me at (904) 914-0740.
How do I get health insurance if I retire early?
Most early retirees choose between COBRA, a Marketplace plan, a private plan, or a spouse's work plan. Leaving your job gives you 60 days to enroll in a Marketplace plan, and many private plans can start on the first of any month. The best fit depends on your retirement income and your health.
Is COBRA worth it if I retire in my 50s?
Usually only as a short bridge. COBRA generally lasts up to 18 months and you pay the full premium plus up to 2%, so if you retire in your 50s you'll need another plan long before Medicare anyway. It can make sense for a few months if you're in the middle of treatment.
Will I qualify for a subsidy in early retirement?
Maybe. Tax credits are based on income, not savings. Most traditional IRA and 401(k) withdrawals count, and so does Social Security, but qualified Roth withdrawals don't. For 2027 coverage, credits generally stop above about $86,560 for a couple.
Can I drop COBRA and switch to a cheaper plan later?
During open enrollment, yes. Outside open enrollment, dropping COBRA on your own doesn't qualify you for a Marketplace special enrollment period. Many private plans can start any month, but it's best to compare before you sign up for COBRA.
Do private plans make sense for early retirees?
For healthy early retirees whose income is over the subsidy line, they often do. They're priced on age, location, and health instead of income. Private plans can use medical underwriting, so not everyone qualifies, and I'll show you the Marketplace option side by side.
Health Insurance After Retirement Before Medicare: Your OptionsIf you retire before 65, you'll need coverage until Medicare starts. Here's how COBRA, the Marketplace, and private plans compare for early retirees.
Earn Just Over the Subsidy Limit for 2027? Here's What HappensUnder current law, Marketplace tax credits stop at 400% of the federal poverty level. Here's what that means for 2027 and what your options are if you're just over the line.
Private Health Insurance vs. ACA Marketplace Plans: What's the Difference?Marketplace plans and private health plans work very differently. Here's how they compare on price, eligibility, pre-existing conditions, and when you can enroll.